- Hampton Inn by Hilton New Paltz, NYNew Paltz9.2
- The Gables of Rhinebeck9.0Rhinebeck
- Margaretville Mountain Inn B&B9.0Margaretville
- Hotel Dylan8.9Woodstock
- Mirbeau Inn & Spa, RhinebeckRhinebeck9.2
- Newly Renovated 3BR Hudson Valley HouseUlster Park9.5
Starlite Motel & SuitesBig Indian8.2- Suites on MainMargaretville7.0
- The Carriage House Loft9.6Kingston
- The StablesKingston9.8
- End of results -