- Lost Whale InnTrinidad9.9
- Gingerbread Mansion9.6Ferndale
- Cottage on the CanalEureka6.3
- Studio 6 Eureka CA Old Town6.7Eureka
- Comfort Inn & Suites Redwood Country7.8Fortuna
- Super 8 by Wyndham Fortuna8.4Fortuna
- Discovery Inn - EurekaEureka5.6
- Benbow Historic Inn8.2Garberville
- Carter House Inns9.3Eureka
- Shaw House InnFerndale8.9
- End of results -