- Lilac VictorianEureka10.0
- Hydrangea Inn8.7Eureka
- The Castle Inn of the Lost CoastShelter Cove7.6
- Coastal Soul Arcata Area California HomeBlue Lake
- Whale Rock SuitesTrinidad8.9
- Ye Olde Danish Inn9.1Ferndale
- Freshwater Lagoon RetreatOrick9.2
- Humboldt Redwoods Inn6.5Garberville
- Benbow Historic Inn8.4Garberville
- Serene Redwood RetreatArcata9.3
- End of results -