- Hibiscus Hideaway - Stay WaihekePalm Beach8.2
- Manea Villa - Stay WaihekePalm Beach10.0
- Crescent Villa - Stay WaihekeOstend9.2
- The Sanctuary- Stay WaihekeOneroa1.0
- Oakura Bay Villa - Stay WaihekeTe Whau Bay9.3
- Wild Days AccommodationPalm Beach8.4
- Villa Casita at Palm Beach by Waiheke UnlimitedPalm Beach7.7
- Oneroa ChaletOneroa8.0
- The Fat Pigeon - Omiha Holiday HomeOmiha8.8
- Waiheke Island Tawa Lodge - Adults OnlyOneroa8.9
- End of results -