- Boatsheds on the Bay, Waiheke IslandOstend8.7
- Guesthouse On Queens9.7Oneroa
- Waiheke Island Motel7.4Ostend
- Nikau Apartments Waiheke IslandOnetangi9.2
- Waiheke Luxury Blue and Green RoomsOstend9.6
- Moana on Waikare - You've Got It MaidOneroa9.5
- Woodside Bay Chalets9.1Ostend
- Jake's Place Oneroa WaihekeOneroa9.6
- Cable Bay Luxury VillaOneroa6.4
- Waiheke Waterfront Lodge9.9Oneroa
- Oneroa Bay VillasOneroa9.0
- The Moorings Studio Apartments - Be My Guest WaihekeOneroa9.3
- 125 Church Bay Cabins, Waiheke Island9.2Oneroa
- Beachfront Enclosure Bay - Waiheke UnlimitedOneroa9.4
- Karaka Sanctuary with Spa Pool by Waiheke UnlimitedOneroa8.3
- Eight on Church - near Mudbrick & Cable BayOneroa9.2
- Moa 30 Runga - Stay WaihekeOneroa9.7
- La Bodega Waiheke IslandSurfdale9.9
- Cable Bay ViewsOneroa9.3
- Fleetwood - Waiheke IslandAuckland10.0
- Blue BirdsOneroa8.7
- Villas Waiheke9.7Onetangi
- Mudbrick CottagesOneroa9.5
- The Oyster InnOneroa9.0
- The Settlers HutOneroa9.5
- Waiheke Island Vineyard Holiday HousesSurfdale9.1
- The Loft at Cypress Ridge Estate - Stay WaihekeOnetangi9.4
- Waiheke Island Resort Conference & Accomodation CentreOstend8.1
- Wild ThymeOneroa9.2
- The Waiheke LodgeOnetangi9.8
- End of results -