- Michelin GuideThe Christopher, The Edgartown CollectionEdgartown9.2
- Michelin GuideAquinnah Cliffs
- Old OrchardEdgartown8.3
- The RootskellerOak Bluffs
- Island DreamOak Bluffs
- Vineyard Haven House - Easy Access to BeachesVineyard Haven
- Michelin GuideMartha's Vineyard
- Marsh WalkOak Bluffs3.5
- Sunset on the VineyardVineyard Haven8.3
- Michelin GuideWoods Hole Oceanographic InstitutionWoods Hole
- Falmouth TidesFalmouth9.0
- Michelin GuideWoods Hole Science AquariumWoods Hole
- West Tisbury InnWest Tisbury7.6
- Brewster HouseOak Bluffs9.0
- Martha's Vineyard Vacation HomeEdgartown8.0
- Michelin GuideOak BluffsOak Bluffs
- Michelin GuideThe Sydney, The Edgartown CollectionEdgartown9.5
- Michelin GuideThe Richard, The Edgartown CollectionEdgartown8.9
- End of results -